12 Comments
User's avatar
M.R.'s avatar

"Like the Dadaists, we should forget everything" and start from scratch? That sounds to me like the opposite of what conservatives should be doing.

Go back to basics, remember true values, bring back beauty and Truth and defend our God-given rights. Not "forget everything" and wing it, moving forward with no template except the rejection of the current. That's just Marxism. Reject the current, reject the traditional, and shoot for the unidentified "new." Lather, rinse, repeat.

No, we need to clearly define our principles, and stand by them without fear. Sure, that involves a fair bit of rejection of the current gatekeepers and pseudo-moralists, but because we have a crystal clear and openly communicated standard to which we adhere, and which we must defend and return to.

Dadaism is a rejection of all standards, reveling in the vapid, inane, grotesque, vulgar, and pointless. It is a truly bad example to use if we're to reject the cultural capture achieved by the modern Marxisits. Indeed, a trend toward "conservative Dadaism" would be playing right into the hands of the deconstructionists and nihilists who are happy to watch it all burn.

Ashley Rindsberg's avatar

Good point - I appreciate what you’re saying and you’re right. But Dadaism was also a reaction to the cultural inanity and frivolity or the First World War when artists were producing portrait after portrait of aristocrats whose regime sent millions of young men in their prime to their slaughter. Art was in service of power. Culture was an expression of the in-group. The Dadaists spat in the eye of the establishment.

M.R.'s avatar

So long as we don't give in to an "anything but this" mindset. We're not just *against* something we dislike; we're *for* something real and important. (Like reality, for instance. 🙃)

Ashley Rindsberg's avatar

This is key. It’s the biggest weakness in fighting cultural Marxism - the Marxists have their One Big Thing, their ideological monolith, that filters everything. And opposing that there’s “free markets”? “Less government”? There’s nothing coherent and cohesive.

M.R.'s avatar

I beg to differ here, too. I know it seems like we're so diverse, those of us who aren't radical Leftists. The tent has indeed gotten increasingly bigger as the opposition has gotten more and more tyrannical and extreme, pushing all but the most radical adherents away.

But we don't have to agree on every little detail in order to agree on a core set of values. Things like free markets and government size are really quite surface level, compared to the nature of reality itself.

Do humans have individual worth? Can people be trusted to generally choose good, if given correct information and left to make the choice? Is there even such a thing as objective good or evil? Things like that, the very pillars upon which any civilization must be founded, are under attack by modern Marxists. I think we can sufficiently agree on those core tenets to make a united stand.

Before we can discuss, for example, whether capitalism or socialism is the more effective vehicle for human prosperity over time, we first have to agree that human prosperity is worth pursuing at all. Which itself is a concept currently under attack by a significant contingent of the Left. ("You'll own nothing and be happy"... "Dogs have more value than humans"... "Thanos was right"...)

Steven Brizel's avatar

You can live a very fulfilling life without being enamored by or worse an intellectual social or cultural captive to the surrounding culture How snd where you spend you spend your spare ti e speaks a lot as to what counts in your life

John McNally's avatar

Excellent post, and the idea of building and claiming a new culture is well expressed and vital. Thank you for articulating so clearly.

Ashley Rindsberg's avatar

Thanks John - I think there’s no I the way forward at this point.